Based on our findings, we cannot recommend that most women should follow a low-fat diet. |
I can see how a lot of women might be confused. |
I can see how a lot of women might be confused. People would like very clear results with a very clear health message, and, unfortunately, these results are not very clear. |
I think we should have lowered expectations of what a lifestyle intervention trial can show over a relatively short period of time. Against a climate of less research funding overall, it's going to be harder to do these kinds of trials in the future. |
I wouldn't worry about the headlines today. There's something happening here. If we persist a little longer, we'll nail it. |
That is a pretty clear signal that there is still something here. I'm hopeful that we will show significant results as we follow these women longer. |
The study is poised to capitalize on the huge advances that have been made in the field of genomics. The best may be yet to come. |
These are secondary analyses and are exploratory to some extent. |
These findings are reassuring for women who want to use these hormones around the age of menopause in the short term for the relief of symptoms. |
This study shows that just reducing total fat intake does not go far enough to have an impact on heart disease risk. |
We as scientists need to be responsible in our public health messages, and provide a balance. But the media picked up the message as the fact these trials are overturning conventional wisdom. They haven't. |
We don't see these as null studies. There are strong suggestions the benefits will show themselves. |
We set out to test a promising but unproven hypothesis that has proven to be less promising than we anticipated. |
We set out to test a promising but unproven hypothesis that has proven to be less promising than we anticipated. This is the nature of science: to have incremental gains and setbacks. We have a duty as scientists to put the best information out there at any given time, even if it can become confusing. |