From what I can tell about this rating system, it looks like the system speculates about the content of what the clubs are going to talk about . . . (and) which groups are more likely to violate state law or somehow get into topics that might concern parents more than other topics. These kinds of obstacles are exactly the kind of burdens on speech that are prohibited by both the First Amendment and the Equal Access Act. |
I still think anyone could look at it and raise question about its constitutionality. It comes back to the question, what does this bill do? |
This bill conflicts with the Equal Access Act that was passed to help guarantee and protect the rights of students. If this passes it will violate state law (and) violate the constitution. |